USA Today
Sep 2, 2009
|
USA
TODAY
Sep2, 2009
In
California, a community rallies to save school
sports
By
Jorge
L. Ortiz,
USA TODAY
DIXON, Calif. — For a while, it appeared budget
cuts at Dixon High School would make it harder
for athletes Jeffery Anderson and Kayla Beal to
impress college recruiters.
Faced
with a $3
million budget shortfall, the school
system 20 miles southwest of Sacramento decided
in February to
discontinue all sports at the town's
middle and high schools for the 2009-10 school
year, a move that could have affected an
estimated 600
of the 1,243 students at Dixon High.
Dozens of students, including Anderson and Beal,
would have faced unattractive options: continue
going to Dixon while playing sports for another
school, or transfer.
"It would have been weird," says Anderson,
starting quarterback on Dixon's football team.
"Especially for us, entering our senior year. We
want to finish where we started."
They
now have that chance because the
school board
reconsidered and decided in May to
provide basic
sports funding — about $110,000,
down from
$280,000 the previous year — and because
the parents and
local community rallied to close part of
the gap.
Through fundraisers
— including a restaurant promotion, a test-drive
program with a dealer and a fundraising drive
where helmets were used to collect money — they
raised more
than $20,000, says
Guy Garcia,
president of the Dixon Schools Athletic
Boosters. The group's
goal for
the school year is
$80,000-$85,000.
Parents now need to provide transportation
to events, and Dixon teams compete in fewer
tournaments, but the high school has
retained its 17
sports from last year and
added boys and
girls water polo.
"It's
a challenge in lots of ways," Brian Dolan,
senior director of human resources and pupil
resources, said of the transportation issues.
"If you have a team of 40, that's a lot more
organizational work. It creates greater
liability. There are series of forms kids have
to fill out, the drivers have to fill out.
There's proof of insurance needed, medical
consent forms for kids for treatment in case of
accidents.
"It's
a lot of management."
Principal Ivan Chaidez
says the chance to play sports provides a
huge incentive
for students to perform academically, if
for no other reason than to stay eligible. "You
can't have a high school without sports.
It's going to be chaos. There's no way to hold
kids accountable or keep kids engaged or
maintain school spirit," he says.
That
school spirit
translates into civic pride in a town of
17,330, where many teens find the main weekend
activity is to "catch a ride to another town,"
said Beal, a senior volleyball player. "There's
a
Wal-Mart,
and that's about it."
Her
comments are echoed by parents, who say most
organized athletic activities in town are geared
toward younger kids. The booster club hopes to
reinstate the stipends of up to $2,800 a year
that varsity coaches received before the money
was taken away in the budget crunch, prompting
some coaches to quit those duties and work only
as teachers.
Others, such as
football coach Scott Winslow and
basketball coach Matt Galindo,
remained as
volunteers even though those tasks can
take up more than 25 hours a week.
Amid
the emphasis on sports, at least one
administrator says other areas are overlooked.
"We
did a survey with students," Dolan says,
"and it was
overwhelming with
students
and also with a lot of
parents,
that sports are
a top priority — ahead of libraries, I'm
sorry to say."
Contributing: Marlen Garcia
At some schools, budget cuts put the kibosh on
sports
At Dixon High School near Sacramento, junior
varsity football players Nick LeBleu, left, and
Ryan Gaudy are playing again after a public
outcry helped restore sports programs.
HIGH
SCHOOL SPORTS IN CRISIS
Budget crisis:
At some schools, budget cuts put sports in
danger
Pinching pennies:
States do what they can to keep programs afloat
Outcry in California:
Community rallies to save sports
Big
switch:
New Mexico opts to change playoff schedules
Giving back:
Phillies outfielder donates to native Hawaii
MISSING IN MICHIGAN
Here
is how one region is dealing with budget
challenges for its athletics departments. Sports
cuts by school in the Lansing, Mich., area:
Bath:
Three varsity assistant coaches and the middle
school athletic director, and a reduction in
supplies and training equipment purchased this
year, to save $35,000.
Corunna:
Some tournaments and equipment that will make up
a 20% cut.
Dansville:
$7,000.
East Lansing:
Three assistant coaches, some transportation,
and the school is no longer paying for bowling
teams.
Fowlerville:
$15,000.
Grand Ledge:
Some junior varsity assistant coaches, booster
clubs taking over some event entry fees, no new
uniforms and less equipment. The school also is
considering providing only one-way
transportation to some events, to offset a cut
of $132,000.
Haslett:
Equipment purchases meant to save $20,000.
Laingsburg:
Two assistant coaches totaling $10,000.
Lansing Everett, Eastern and Sexton:
One football, one wrestling, two swimming and
two track assistants at each school.
Okemos:
One assistant coach, still need to cut $7,000
during the school year.
Owosso:
Some travel expenses.
Portland:
Will no longer sponsor bowling teams.
St. Johns:
Supply purchases totaling $10,000.
Stockbridge:
Entire uniform budget. Programs must fund raise
for replacements.
Williamston:
Assistant athletic director in charge of, in
part, scheduling and meeting representation.
By
the Lansing (Mich.) State Journal
By
Marlen
Garcia,
USA TODAY
Instead of gearing up to run cross country for
Grove City High School in Ohio, Andy Bennett is
training for a marathon.
It
will give the 16-year-old some consolation
because sports programs and clubs at his school
have been shut down. An hour after the last bell
each afternoon, it's lights out at the school.
Bennett and his classmates won't have
homecoming, prom or a student government —
activities that, like sports, are fixtures in
American high schools but no longer exist at
Grove City because of a financial crisis.
That's
the plight of all students who attend
South-Western City Schools, which serves part of
Columbus
and nearby towns and is Ohio's sixth-largest
school district. The district has been in dire
financial straits for years and is being
squeezed further by the economic downturn. By
canceling activities, the district cut $2.5
million in expenses, district spokeswoman Sandy
Nekoloff says.
"I
thought it was the worst thing in the world,"
Bennett says of the school board's decision to
cancel activities after a proposed property tax
hike was rejected by voters in August, the third
time it failed.
In
this district, no one has been spared, not even
Grove City High's marching band. "There's no
football games. There's nowhere for the marching
band to march," Nekoloff says.
High
schools across the USA are reporting that the
recession has led to similar financial
difficulties for extracurricular programs,
forcing cost-cutting that is particularly
painful now, as fall sports seasons open. From
Hawaii to Rhode Island, school systems are
trimming compensation for coaches, eliminating
transportation, adding or increasing athletic
fees for students, holding fundraising drives,
cutting back on night games to save electricity
costs and dropping some sports and related
events altogether.
In
Nevada, this "is going to be the worst year
financially for school districts in history —
and 2010-11 is going to be worse," says Eddie
Bonine, executive director of the Nevada
Interscholastic Activities Association. "We may
be told to do more next year."
In
Michigan, Jamie Gent, athletics director at
Haslett High near Lansing, says, "There's no
money, period. We're coming to a stage in the
next three years that if things don't get
better, (it could damage) sports altogether. Who
do you pick? What stays? What sport doesn't
stay?"
Bennett says he was close to transferring to a
school outside his district so he could earn his
third varsity letter in cross country. His
parents were willing to pay more than $3,000 for
him to attend an out-of-district public school
or private school, he says.
He
knows of other families who are paying steep
tuition so their teens can play sports.
Such a
move from Grove City would have been difficult
academically and socially, Bennett says. He is a
top student taking Advanced Placement courses
and didn't want to hurt his chances of getting
into his dream college, the Air Force Academy.
"I've been in the Grove City public system
forever," he says. "Switching to another school
with no friends was not very appealing."
Some
athletes may miss out
The
mood at school is grim, others say. "We're going
to have all these idle hands," says Drew
Eschbach, who was the cross country coach.
Top-tier athletes will be OK, Eschbach says,
because they will transfer to schools with
better-funded programs or form their own clubs.
He says he worries about average athletes who
will miss out on the collegiality and sense of
belonging that a team or club can provide.
Some
in the community have accused school system
officials of canceling activities to strong-arm
residents into passing a tax increase. Nekoloff
says activities were canceled after other cuts
failed to help solve the financial problems.
"We've had $22 million in reductions and more
than 330 positions reduced over the past three
years," she says.
Residents will vote on a scaled-back property
tax increase in November. The district estimates
the new proposal would cost the owner of a
$100,000 home an additional $18.89 a month in
property taxes. The median household income for
the area was $54,965 in 2007, according to the
U.S. Census Bureau.
Pay-to-play plan considered
District officials are studying a pay-to-play
model, which increasingly has been used across
the country. Nekoloff says if South-Western's
proposed tax increase passes, the board could
bring back activities under this system and
students would share costs with the district.
At
most schools, pay-to-play fees cover a portion
of a team's expenses and school districts kick
in the rest. But those amounts can be
disproportionate, as is the case at Brighton
High School in Michigan.
Brighton offers 32 sports and fields 98 teams,
enviable by any school's standards. But the
district funds only 38% of the athletic
department's nearly $1.5 million in
expenditures; the other 62% is self-generated
through fundraisers and fees, athletics director
John Thompson says.
Athletes pay $175 a sport, although the fee for
a third sport is waived. Students also pay
transportation fees ranging from $30 to $70 a
sport. Fees are waived for those with financial
hardship.
"We've
started chipping away at the model that existed
when I was a kid," Thompson says.
"Unfortunately, one day sports will be out there
for people who have money. We can say we'll take
care of those without money, but I can tell you
it will be the kids with talent. The average kid
is going to get left behind. That whole
development factor, they're going to miss out on
it."
Contributing: Geoff Kimmerly of the Lansing
(Mich.) State Journal; Chris Gabel of the Reno
Gazette-Journal
|